By Marc Shaw
Roughly one in three title searches turns up something that has to be cleared before a deal can close, and the issues repeat themselves with surprising regularity. The most common title defects involve unpaid liens, recording mistakes, missing heirs, unrecorded easements and the quiet category that causes the most litigation after closing: boundary problems.
Title defects, surveying errors, and boundary disputes are related problems, and the way you protect yourself against all three happens before you sign, not after. Securing title insurance in PA through an experienced agency like World Wide Land Transfer makes sure your property rights and boundaries are thoroughly examined and legally protected prior to closing.
A title search reconstructs the ownership history of a parcel from public records, and most problems are clerical rather than fraudulent.
The categories below account for the large majority of what gets flagged in a commitment:
The first four can usually be cleared with payoffs, affidavits or corrective deeds before closing. The last two are different, because they depend on a survey, and surveys are where the record and the physical world stop agreeing.
Surveying errors in real estate are rarely the result of sloppy fieldwork. More often they come from the source documents a surveyor has to work with: deed descriptions written in the 1890s using metes and bounds tied to a tree that no longer exists, subdivision plats that were never recorded, or two adjoining deeds that describe overlapping strips of the same land.
Typical causes of property line survey errors include:
A boundary survey for a standard residential lot typically runs $500 to $1,500 depending on acreage and terrain, while an ALTA/NSPS Land Title Survey for a commercial site generally starts around $2,500 and climbs with parcel count. The ALTA/NSPS Minimum Standard Detail Requirements set out exactly what that survey has to show, which is why lenders on commercial deals ask for one by name.
An encroachment title defect exists when a structure crosses a boundary line, whether it belongs to you or to the neighbor. A detached garage two feet over the line, a driveway that uses the adjoining lot to turn, a shed built after the last survey, and roof eaves extending past a side yard are all common examples.
Encroachments matter for three reasons. They can give the neighbor an adverse possession or prescriptive easement claim over time, they can make a parcel unmarketable when the next buyer’s lender sees the survey, and they can force removal of a structure at the owner’s expense. Our commercial department, headed by Jeff Lender, sees the sharpest version of this on multi-parcel industrial deals where a loading apron or rail spur crosses from one lot to another.
Property boundary disputes escalate fast when they start with a letter from an attorney.
The sequence that resolves most of them, in rough order of cost, looks like this:
If you are asking how to fix a boundary dispute with a neighbor before anyone has spent money, start with the survey and a conversation. Judges resolve these cases on the same evidence either way.
This distinction gets glossed over at the closing table and then matters enormously later. A lender’s policy protects the mortgage holder up to the loan balance and nothing more. It does not pay you a dollar if a defect surfaces.
When buyers weigh owner’s title insurance vs lender’s title insurance, the practical answer is that the lender’s policy is required and the owner’s policy is the one that protects your equity, your legal defense costs and your resale. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau makes the same point: the policy your lender requires is not coverage for you. When both policies are issued together, one is discounted, so covering both parties costs far less than two full premiums.
Standard policies contain a survey exception, which excludes anything an accurate survey would have disclosed. Removing or narrowing that exception is how you get real owner’s title insurance survey coverage, and it usually requires that you provide a current survey the insurer will accept.
Endorsement pricing varies by state because many rates are filed or promulgated. Most residential endorsements run from a flat $50 to $250 each, while commercial endorsements are often priced as a percentage of the base premium.
World Wide Land Transfer reviews commitments, survey exceptions and endorsement options on residential and commercial transactions every day, and the time to raise a boundary question is while the file is still open. Contact our team to talk through coverage on your specific parcel.